When we last checked in with Jim Carrey, he was declaring his love for Emma Stone in a creepy but hilarious video. So it was probably appropriate that Carrey sung ‘Creep,’ Radiohead’s ode to awkward longing, when he crashed New York City club Arlene’s Grocery’s Friday karaoke party.

Watch Carrey’s not-bad-at-all interpretation of the alt-rock classic below.

Bonus Carrey. He also sang the Smashing Pumpkins’ ‘Bullet With Butterfly Wings’ at the club:

[via Gawker]